Thursday, August 27, 2009

Islamic Banking in Pakistan: A consumer perspective

THE Idea of Islamic Banking is still hot these days in Pakistan. Either completely new Islamic institute are being emerged or recent traditional banks are opening additional branches focusing in Shariah-based Financing products/services. But still consumers doubt that how much are they Islamic? Three years back, Fazal Ahmed, chief financial officer of the Islamic Investment Bank quoted that “Pakistan followed Malaysia and Bahrain considered the role models of Islamic banking while it formulated its regulations, now Pakistan has the best possible framework for Islamic banking that it can”. But, at the end of the day, government institutions and authorities cannot judge whether they have proved themselves or not while consumers do.

 

Now, according to the average consumer of the Islamic banks in Pakistan they still have doubt in their mind from the scratch to the main services provided by Islamic Banks.

 

Consumers would be open to the thought of acquire Islamic banking products and services given that the organization that is offering the service is renowned, and better customer service features such as ATM access, phone banking and so on, are offered. This provides a great prospect for Islamic financial organizations in a market that already have many other competitive existing commercial banks. If Islamic financial organizations can make on their understanding and status in the monetary world, and can offer Islamic banking products/services in non Islamic markets such as Singapore, United Kingdom, Australia, they can plan to increase an emergent consumer base of the local residents in Pakistan, some of who may have beforehand excused themselves from dealing with the usual financial organizations because of the use of interest. The consumers still also believe on the fact the lack of consciousness about some basic concepts and philosophy of Islamic banking. In Pakistan, a number of consumers would not adopt halal banking products because they feel insecure that what will happen if credit facilities were taken away. In the Islamic monetary structure money is not lent out, as an alternative it is an asset-backed scheme where monetary organizations invest in projects. Consequently, financial organizations deal in equity, not debt. To counter this inadequacy, some banks have started issuing ‘debit’ cards. These cards are alike to the credit cards excluding the actuality that they use the consumers own funds as an alternative of trust on any credit. Another concern is that of sharing profits and not losses. A lot of consumers who have been using the Islamic banking services were not educated about the loss sharing concept earlier. This would designate that some economic organizations have been assuring profits. In fact, it breaches the fundamental law of Islamic financing structure that is, relating compensations to risk. Any kind of money earned on investment without risk is simply interest more willingly than profit.

 

So, it reveals the fact that, in order to recognize how the Islamic structure makes a distinction between profit and interest, they have to look at the dissimilarities in financial beliefs. Because past experiances have already shown that the rationale of ‘monetary and financial standing’ is very important for a consumer to select a particular bank. In capitalist theory, capital and entrepreneurs are taken care of as two separate identities of production where the first identity acquires interest and the second identity is permitted to get the profit. It is implicit that interest is a fixed return to offer capital, and profit can simply be produced after allocating the fixed return to land, labor and capital. On the contrary, the Islamic monetary system does not regard as capital and entrepreneurs as separate identities of production. It accepts as true that each individual who puts in capital in the figure of money to a business enterprise assumes the risk of loss and as a result is permitted to a proportional share in the actual profit. The system is caring of the entrepreneur, who in a capitalist economy would have to make fixed interest repayments even when the venture is making a loss. Capital has a fundamental aspect of entrepreneurship, until now as the risk of the industry is apprehensive and for that reason, rather than a fixed return as interest, it develops profit. So, as much profit one earn of the business, the more return on capital. The profit would be privileged if there are no fixed interest repayments. In this fashion the profits produced by the money-making activities in the public are uniformly dispersed among those who have given capital to the organization. In this way, an integration of social responsibility and extra Islamic values in rewarding consumers’ needs to be worthy of ultimate consideration as it signifies an excellent and basic discrimination between Islamic and conventional banking systems, and potentially competent to push Islamic banking to better pinnacle in securing consumers’ gratefulness and response.

 

Top researchers in the area of Islamic Finance have affirmed that assurance made by organizations that consumers will take delivery of a set rate of return without having to acquire losses are prohibited and immoral. Thus far, not only are financial organizations enduring the practice but government societies in Muslim nations are also contributing venture openings with certain income. Taking into consideration, that the Muslim administration is accountable for overseeing the structure in order to battle the prohibited practices of monetary institutes, by giving definite returns; the governments are seen to be overlooking the performance of the monetary organizations. Even though these proceedings may assist Islamic Banks develop in the short run, but in the long run overall cost will prevail over the profit in shape of damage to the repute and legitimacy. Such progress also offer ammunition to the detractors of the system who are previously questioning whether the structure is nothing more than an interest based system operating under the guise of profit.

 

The most essential information discovered by the past behaviors is that consumer satisfaction over and over again is directly related to the quality of services that Islamic banks offer. The excellence of services comprises of factors like taking care of consumers with politeness and admiration; workforce capability to put across faith and self-assurance; effectiveness and efficacy in managing any operation; and well-informed and attentiveness in offering clarifications and answers relating to the products and services of an Islamic bank.

 

As a result, Islamic bankers can no more rely only at marketing strategy of pulling religious and holy consumers towards them who might only worry about Islamicity of banking services. Some significant insights acknowledged on the bases of different thoughts of consumer baking selection criterion entails the requirement for Islamic banks to improve its quality of services which is at the present measured as an important success factor that have an effect on an institute’s competitiveness. With respect to the standing of a variety of bank selection criterion, some of these would undoubtedly revolutionize accordingly of people having turn out to be extra conscious of the culture of Islamic banking. For instance, media advertising would be probable to have an extreme good impact on Muslims. The aspiration by Muslims to be compensated a high rate of interest have to decrease. In case of non- Muslims, media advertising may turn out to be well rated accordingly of being uncovered to revealing bank promotion.

 

Besides this, an additional considerable subject, which needs awareness, is the need to strengthen community learning and understanding towards the distinguishing features of Islamic banks and how it may beneficially go with the concern of consumers in their economic transactions. Islamic banks have latent of being advertised to different sectors of consumers who are worried with the legality of the ability from Islamic viewpoint and those who try to find for service value, handiness and well-organized business. Customer learning programs are for that reason vital if they are to amplify the level of customer consciousness about the distinctive features of Islamic banking and the range of services and products offered by it.

 

On the whole, after consumers have been uncovered to the ethnicity of Islamic banking, it would be anticipated that consumer’s knowledge of what Islamic banking engages would enhance and their thoughts towards this type of banking should vary. The change would be estimated to be much bigger in local consumers. Similarly with the standing of the different banking selection criterion. Shifts would be likely, extra predominant with banking customers throughout the country.

 

(This article is contributed by Fahad Ramzan, courtesy: Pakistan Times!)

Posted via email from IBFN (Islamic Banking & Finance Network) at Posterous

Monday, May 11, 2009

How it differs - Islamic vs Conventional credit cards?

Muslims always say that their divine religion, always present solutions to every problem. Bank interest is always considers as an issue in mankind history, if we exclude banks history from there!
 
No one, regardless of religion, likes the interest and especially interest on Credit Cards. A credit card is a modern day tool that allows users to carry out financial transactions using plastic card.
 
What solution is there in Islamic banking to resolve the issues of credit card interest?
 
- high annual maintenance fee (AMF) without monthly interest
- a buying & selling methodology
- prohibition of usage to buy haram items
 
A common man always compares a traditional credit card with an Islamic credit card and finds very less difference! why????

Posted via email from IBFN (Islamic Banking & Finance Network) at Posterous

Thursday, May 7, 2009

A conventional and an Islamic bank - side by side!

When yesterday, a colleague of mine who is a banker too, has asked me as "have you noticed the growth of Islamic banks in last 10 years all over the world?" I just responded by saying "yes" without any arguments!
 
But the fact is having much more depth than for any new theory. Why the world is switching to Islamic mode of banking which outlines prohibition of "riba" (interest) and world's top class banks are opening Islamic banking windows!
 
Is this a real fact that world financial leaders -even in the current crisis of crunch- have noticed or view Islamic banking as a positive change or it is something else?
 
By looking at various top class banks, it is clear that with conventional banking they do have a sort of Islamic Banking window! reasons might be different but the fact is that is exists!

Posted via email from IBFN (Islamic Banking & Finance Network) at Posterous

Monday, May 4, 2009

Why so much pain!!!


A middle aged lady has walked into the branch of a bank and started talking to the front desk banking officer:
 
"I want to open a bank account."
 
"Madam, for what reason, if I may ask you!"
 
"Yes, I want to do a time deposite"
 
"Ok"
 
"Are you looking for higher rates?"
 
"Off course, yeah"
 
"Shall I suggest you to look at our non-interest base products?"
 
"No, I heard about that and its a great pain!"
 
"May I help you have minimum fuss about that?"
 
"No thanks"
 
This was the conversation and the talented relationship officer had tried to divert the customer towards Islamic banking but failed due to customer satisfaction issue.

Posted via email from IBFN (Islamic Banking & Finance Network) at Posterous

Tuesday, April 28, 2009

Why Interest? by Muhammad Ali Nadeem


When people use to ask me as “why interest is prohibited” in our society? Look at the banks structure, we have some money, we are going to open an account and deposit our money, probably hard earned, to make some money out of it? They usually give me few examples such as “I am 65 years old retired government officer, I have received approximately rupees 500,000 at the time of my retirement, and now I feel that I don’t have some skills and strengths to invest that money in any business, hence I am putting them in a bank as a time-deposit where I could earn some money at the rate of 5% or 6% per annum.” I would get some money to bear my living expenses as well as there wouldn’t be any risk and my money would be secured and could be enchased any moment. If I invest it in any business, say if I open a shop there’s no guarantee that it would earn me some money to manage my expenses and the risk of failure remains there for ever!

I never use to answer them with logics and arguments inviting them to learn Islamic finance concept. I only tell them that there are many Islamic banks in Pakistan, you may invest your money in such Islamic financial institutions and get profit at the same rate of interest, to avoid interest which is a prohibited concept in Islam!

The response was not very much positive!

Posted via email from IBFN (Islamic Banking & Finance Network) at Posterous

Thursday, April 23, 2009

Money Matters: Usury in Hinduism and Buddhism


Among the oldest known references to usury are to be found in ancient Indian religious manuscripts and Jain (1929) provides an excellent summary of these in his work on Indigenous Banking in India. 

 

The earliest such record derives from the Vedic texts of Ancient India (2,000-1,400 BC) in which the “usurer” (kusidin) is mentioned several times and interpreted as any lender at interest.  More frequent and detailed references to interest payment are to be found in the later Sutra texts (700-100 BC), as well as the Buddhist Jatakas (600-400 BC).  It is during this latter period that the first sentiments of contempt for usury are exressed.  For example, Vasishtha, a well known Hindu law-maker of that time, made a special law which forbade the higher castes of Brahmanas (priests) and Kshatriyas (warriors) from being usurers or lenders at interest. 

 

Also, in the Jatakas, usury is referred to in a demeaning manner: “hypocritical ascetics are accused of practising it”.

 

By the second century AD, however, usury had become a more relative term, as is implied in the Laws of Manu of that time:  “Stipulated interest beyond the legal rate being against (the law), cannot be recovered:  they call that a usurious way (of lending)” (Jain, 1929: 3-10).  This dilution of the concept of usury seems to have continued through the remaining course of Indian history so that today, while it is still condemned in principle, usury refers only to interest charged above the prevailing socially accepted range and is no longer prohibited or controlled in any significant way.


See and download the full gallery on posterous

Posted via email from ibfn's posterous

The concept of “usury”


The concept of “usury” has a long historical life, throughout most of which it has been understood to refer to the practice of charging financial interest in excess of the principle amount of a loan, although in some instances and more especially in more recent times, it has been interpreted as interest above the legal or socially acceptable rate.

 

Accepting this broad definition for the moment, the practice of usury can be traced back approximately four thousand years (Jain, 1929), and during its subsequent history it has been repeatedly condemned, prohibited, scorned and restricted, mainly on moral, ethical, religious and legal grounds.  Among its most visible and vocal critics have been the religious institutions of Hinduism, Buddhism, Judaism, Islam and Christianity. 

 

To this list may be added ancient Western philosophers and politicians, as well as various modern socio-economic reformers.  It is the objective of this paper to outline briefly the history of this critique of usury, to examine reasons for its repeated denouncement and, finally, to intuitively assess the relevance of these arguments to today’s predominantly interest-based global economy. 

 

The scope will not extend to a full exploration of some of the proposed modern alternatives to usury, except to describe the growing practice of Islamic banking as an example.

Posted via email from ibfn's posterous